Skip to content

Consumer Groups Push Back Against New Airline Delay Rule

FTA-AirlineDelayRule_Web

A controversial new Department of Transportation (DOT) rule that could leave air travelers with fewer protections during flight disruptions is facing a legal challenge from FlyersRights, the nation’s largest airline passenger organization.

FlyersRights has filed a petition for review with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, challenging a rule that would reclassify 10 causes of flight delays and cancellations as events outside an airline’s control. The change could reduce airlines’ incentive and obligation to provide assistance to passengers stranded by these disruptions.

Originally expected to take effect in October 2026, the rule has since been delayed until Feb. 1, 2027. Among the 10 reclassified events are government shutdowns, cybersecurity attacks, unscheduled maintenance and the removal of unruly passengers. Under the new classifications, airlines would no longer be expected to provide certain assistance, such as hotel accommodations and meal or beverage credits, to passengers affected by these disruptions.

The DOT acknowledged that the change would reduce “the total value of amenities and compensation currently provided by air carriers to consumers.” The agency invoked a “good cause” exception under the Administrative Procedure Act to issue the rule as a direct final rule, bypassing the usual public comment period.

FlyersRights argues that the rule is “procedurally invalid, arbitrary, capricious, and otherwise contrary to law.” Its petition contends that the FAA Reauthorization Act does not authorize the DOT to redefine airlines’ substantive responsibilities or alter passenger rights through a reporting rule.

“A change in reporting classifications is not permission to reduce passenger rights,” said Paul Hudson, president of FlyersRights. Hudson argues that an airline's choice of a statistical reporting code should not determine whether it is responsible for a disruption or has met its legal and contractual obligations to passengers. He also criticized the rule for potentially shifting costs back to travelers, including in cases involving mechanical problems that are the airline's responsibility.

FlyersRights is not alone in opposing the change. The American Economic Liberties Project, Consumer Action, National Consumers League and Travelers United have also signed a letter to Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy urging the DOT to withdraw the rule.

Scroll To Top